Yesterday evening Radio 2 broadcast the final edition of Big Band Special after a 34 year innings. The final coda has been played and my woefully under represented music genre of choice takes a huge body blow and a giant step away from any sort of mainstream media presence.
This post started life as a number of Facebook posts regarding cuts to the output of the BBC Big Band's broadcast output on Radio 2. I've added a little personal history and observations of some recent musical adventures which hopefully suggest that big band music is not in the death throes.
'Well done the BBC, another winner'.
Once again you have taken a giant leap forward with your gradual attempt at the euthanasia of big band music in the UK with your axing of Big Band Special. First you scrapped 'Band Parade', which for those of you too young to remember was a weekly showcase for professional (and occasionally semipro) big bands from across the country. More recently in the midst ...of a smokescreen of lies you did away with the National Rehearsal Band Competition which provided me (aged 15) with my first proper studio session in the old Maida Vale 6, and provided an invaluable showcase for countless musicians who have subsequently, and quite deservedly become household names in our industry. I have for some time considered the BBC to be virtually irrelevant with regard to the cultural life of our nation, and in a week which has seen the passing of David Jacobs, a lifetime champion of quality music, you manage to hit the spot once again. Well done. Not so much Maida Vale as Maida Mistake. (Originally posted to Facebook, 4/9/13).
I have some history with big band music. My introduction to the idiom started in the late 60s and developed in the 70s. My recollection is my Dad buying a Bang and Olufsen hi fi in 1968 and playing Buddy Rich's records constantly. I'd never heard music reproduced with such power and clarity prior to then and the effect was profound to say the least. This was followed by Stan Kenton, Basie, Ellington, Maynard Ferguson Thad Jones/Mel Lewis and Woody Herman. All of this music reflected the present day, and whilst it had its roots in the past it didn't sound anything other than contemporary to my pre-teen ears. It was a few years later before I really heard any of the 'swing era' recordings and whilst impressive in their own way I doubt my career path would have taken the trajectory that it has had I heard the older music first.
I took my first steps as a participant in my early teens. Back then the Musicians Union had an incentive whereby each branch (and there were masses of MU branches back then; even Leamington Spa had its own branch) could sponsor a 'rehearsal band'. Free music was made available to members, home-grown British writing largely from the NYJO stable and most of it of a reasonable standard. At a time when contemporary American arrangements were a bit scarce in the UK this provided an opportunity for musicians to get their teeth into something new rather than warming over the old stock dance band charts of the 50s and 60s.
Even better than that, the Midland district of the MU had an annual big band competition. On a Sunday at the end of October musicians would descend upon the Matrix Ballroom in Coventry and battle would commence. I think I went there for the first time in 1977. Bands would set up at either end of the room and each play three or for tunes including a 'test piece', performed by all participating ensembles. I recall about 11 bands taking part when the contest was at its height. Birmingham, Nottingham, Derby, Wolverhampton, Leamington Spa, Coventry and more all were represented and at the end of the day the panel of judges would cast their verdict. Other than a trophy there wasn't an awful lot at stake besides honour if I may be candid, although a lucky standout player might just get a mention in an MU branch newsletter or, <sharp intake of breath>, 'Crescendo' magazine. Having said that it did provide a valuable showcase not only to bands but individual instrumentalists as well and I developed a whole raft of contacts from my involvement. It wasn't called 'networking' back then.
Even better than that, the Midland district of the MU had an annual big band competition. On a Sunday at the end of October musicians would descend upon the Matrix Ballroom in Coventry and battle would commence. I think I went there for the first time in 1977. Bands would set up at either end of the room and each play three or for tunes including a 'test piece', performed by all participating ensembles. I recall about 11 bands taking part when the contest was at its height. Birmingham, Nottingham, Derby, Wolverhampton, Leamington Spa, Coventry and more all were represented and at the end of the day the panel of judges would cast their verdict. Other than a trophy there wasn't an awful lot at stake besides honour if I may be candid, although a lucky standout player might just get a mention in an MU branch newsletter or, <sharp intake of breath>, 'Crescendo' magazine. Having said that it did provide a valuable showcase not only to bands but individual instrumentalists as well and I developed a whole raft of contacts from my involvement. It wasn't called 'networking' back then.
That said, to an ambitious young musician taking his first steps in the industry it all felt like a hell of a big deal, and that Sunday was an eagerly anticipated highlight of the year. I gained invaluable experience from these contests and remember those times with a mix of affection and gratitude.
The Musicians Union big band contest was as nothing however, when compared to the BBC National Rehearsal Band Competition. Now this was the big deal.
Some months went by and I'd sort of forgotten about it and was busy doing my first pro gig playing (roasting!) for a 15 act circus at the NEC with a 12 piece band, when such things were the norm. One day we were between shows and I was given a message to call the BBC in Birmingham. Not only had the band won the junior section of the competition but I had had seen off the adult opposition and been awarded the Jack Parnell drum award. Exciting times; my picture in the paper, first time in a TV studio, first radio interview and sometime after, a Radio 2 broadcast from Golders Green Hippodrome.
For a young musician that was an amazing experience culminating a live concert to an audience full of the great and good of the industry. If very fortunate one might even be looked upon with favour by the mighty Lord Ashton of Wealdstone. I wasn't, but that's neither here nor there.
The band won again the following year, and the broadcast fell on my 18th birthday. I still have the recording and I'm proud of what I did.
This account is not unique by any stretch of the imagination and this was an experience shared by countless musicians both on the first rung of the ladder, or receiving overdue recognition after decades at the coal face.
I remember the day I found out that it had been scrapped. Don Lusher had just announced his retirement and he had thrown a party at his house in Cheam for former colleagues and associates from around the industry. Whilst there I bumped into Ray Harvey and Sheila Tracy, both of whom were bordering on incandescent at the announcement that the BBC had scrapped the National Big Band Competition after roughly 30 years. Ray had produced pretty much from day one and Sheila had hosted the show (in her inimitable style) after Alan Dell called it a day.
Anyway the Beeb got rid of it. Shortly thereafter I found a thread about it on the also defunct BBC jazz webpage and clashed with somebody who called himself 'Mr Stevie' and was clearly a BBC insider and was making comments along the lines of, "The next contest will be announced soon". From my experience chez Lusher I was able to refute that unequivocally. I think that was 2005 and we're still waiting. (Incidentally, since this was first posted to Facebook in the early part of September the self same 'Mr Stevie' has broken cover with a blog post about the BBC's orchestras through history).
I've no idea why it got canned, but in one of my posts re the recent developments concerning the BBC Big Band I couldn't help thinking that all those young people coming through year upon year were fostering support for the big band genre and bringing in new blood.
Perhaps this runs contrary to BBC ideals, who knows? It almost feels as if big band music has been put into a critical care unit and is gradually having its nutrition cut to the point where it will fade for the last time and leave us forever.
I find it slightly odd that the BBC manages to support a station called BBC1Xtra. For the uninitiated among you this is 24/7 coverage of the urban music scene. Were that my music of choice I would probably seek out a more authentic source such as an independent or pirate broadcaster, not some posh boys trying to be 'street'; and before you play the 'grumpy old fart' card I should point out that I'm younger than Tim Westwood.
Is there such a word as 'geriatrification'? (to deliberately make something old before its time). Spell check is saying no, so maybe I just coined a phrase. All too often this music falls victim to stereotyping and whenever 'big' and 'band' get used in the same sentence out come all the bog standard cliches. You know the deal; Glenn Miller, the White Cliffs of Vera Lynn and people in WW2 fancy dress. If you want to dress up in WW2 military garb and dance in an aircraft hangar please feel free to do so. Have the time of your life in fact. I've played countless such gigs over the years and they can be great fun in the right company. Problems start when the pygmies in the media start portraying an entire genre thus. The truth is that was just a small moment in a one hundred year timeline. It just so happened that that particular era in big band music provided a backdrop to the truly cataclysmic events of WW2. Whilst arguably the high watermark of popularity this era shouldn't be allowed to define the genre but it seems to do so. When people speak of 'rock and roll' they're obviously not necessarily talking about Bill Haley, Buddy Holly and razor wielding teddy boys. Why, then, should a couple of years in the early 40s be the benchmark for all that big band music was, is and still could become? There was no better example of media ignorance than the recent trailer for something on Sky called 'Chickens', a comedy set in World War 1; complete with music bed featuring Count Basie and Glenn Miller, although there have been a couple of major gaffs in period dramas too. I remember one recent effort where a 1930s dance band played music that was about as 'period incorrect' as it's possible to imagine.
I've been a big band leader since 1982. Thirty years of studying audience demographics teaches you a thing or two. There's no denying that the upper age for big band shows has always been higher than for other genres apart from classical, but then it would be. Big band music (like jazz) has been around for longer and quality engenders loyalty. Give people something good enough and you've got them for a lifetime. Give them One Direction and they'll be off in another direction as soon as the proverbial wind changes. The other day I bumped into some guys who had been taken to one of our concerts at Cadogan Hall when they were in the first year of secondary school. They're at college now and recently came to another gig. They're still into it.
Our band played a show recently at a very prestigious UK school. Their music students are on a three line whip as far as attendance goes. Other students are able to attend at no charge if they wish. I subsequently heard that more sixth formers had chosen to attend our gig than any other previous presentations at the school. They 'got it' too. Neither they nor the general public in attendance needned to be softened up with the all too predictable Miller/Rat Pack offerings. Big band jazz was what they had come to hear, and it was what they got.
Two days later I played a big budget corporate event (nice to see those making a comeback) with somebody else's big band. Here the offering was much more commercial. A non-specialist audience (80% women, mostly under 40) received the music rapturously. Nobody asked if we would play 'Valerie' even once, and the roar of recognition on hearing the hackneyed introduction of that dreaded warhorse 'In the Mood' surprised even me.
Jazz is a tortured soul in a lot of ways. I've often admired rock music for its sense of self assurance and lack of obsession with constantly re-inventing and innovating. A lot of rock music sounds just the way it did 40 (or sometimes more) years ago and yet it rarely if ever gets pushed off the airwaves. Undeniably the cutting edge of jazz and improvised music needs to retain its sharpness, (well represented on BBC Radio 3) the mainstream will remain fresh and relevant if nurtutred properly. If only somebody could make the powers that be realise how much of the great music recorded from the 30s to the present day is actually really rather 'hip', 'edgy', 'challenging' and ever so slightly 'urban', not to mention 'urbane'. It's about the perception of the content and how you put it over.
So, dead or alive? Recent experience say to me very much alive. If anything the scene, especially in London, is currently more vibrant than at any time I can remember in the 21 years I've been here. New bands with leaders such as Callum Au, Reuben Fowler, Mike Gorman, Graeme Taylor, Richard Shepherd and many others are providing a huge injection of musical positivity: writing new music and breathing new life into classic repertoire and familiar compositions. Also Ronnie Scott's has its own in-house big band. Every show they play sells out. This is progress. These are positive new developments.
Hopefully inadvertant euthanasia through lack of media coverage can be avoided. It almost feels as if the BBC's line on this runs counter to the sentiment of the general public. (Surprise, surprise!) Perhaps they consider big band aficionados to be Ukip supporting, Daily Mail reading nasty Little Englanders who need to be put in their place. Don't bother posting comments on the Radio 2 website btw, you'll get deleted in less time than it takes to say, "Coming up next on Radio 2, Jessie J and Dizzee Rascal, innit".
I've spent a lot of the last 35 plus years playing big band music of all kinds, everything from the old army uniforms to the emperor's new clothes. This music has given me many, many unforgettable career moments; I've gained a profile and spent a fortune and I'd really miss it if it were no longer around.